American Financial Services Association - 11th Circuit Agrees with AFSA on Hunstein
Member login
American Financial Services Association

11th Circuit Agrees with AFSA on Hunstein

Blog Posts

By a vote of 8 to 4, judges in the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals held that the plaintiff in Hunstein v. Preferred Collection and Management Servs., Inc., failed to allege a concrete harm that would provide Article III standing to pursue claims in federal court, and accordingly ordered the district court’s judgment be vacated and the case dismissed. Chief Judge Bill Pryor in a concurrence indicated that the case was an “exercise in simplicity” following the U.S. Supreme Court’s TransUnion decision from last summer.

As background, earlier this year AFSA and six other trades filed a brief asking that the 11th Circuit Court review a prior decision made by a panel of the court’s judges in Hunstein.

En banc review is required because the Court’s decision prohibits not only third-party debt collectors, but the entire financial services industry—including banks, credit unions, and finance and mortgage companies—from using third-party service providers that are vital to servicing of loans, the trades wrote, “These service providers make financial services more affordable and efficient for consumers and are particularly important now in reaching customers impacted by COVID-19. The decision also threatens to limit the ability to share information necessary for buying, selling, and securitizing loans, which is critical to the financial services market. None of this was intended by the drafters of a statute meant to curb abusive debt collection practices.”

The original panel of judges held that a debt collector who shared debt-related personal information with a third-party vendor for collection letter printing and mailing violated the Fair Debt Collection Practices Act (FDCPA), and also acknowledged that its ruling had the potential to substantially expand the scope of the FDCPA because the debt collection industry generally relies on mail and other vendors. However, the court discounted that concern. The opinion held that while Hunstein may be the first case in which a debtor brings suit against a debt collector for disclosure of personal information to a mail vendor, that hardly proves that such disclosures are lawful. The ruling was considered significant because debt collectors transmit consumer personal information in their third-party vendor relationships frequently.

AFSA will share full analysis of the ruling after it completes its review of the decision.

11th Circuit Agrees with AFSA on Hunstein
Sep 08, 2022

By a vote of 8 to 4, judges in the 11th Circuit Court of Appeals held that the plaintiff in Hunstein v. Preferred Collection and Management Servs., Inc., failed to allege a concrete harm that would provide Article III standing to pursue claims… Read the rest

LISTEN | End-of-Summer Federal Update
Sep 08, 2022

Join the AFSA Extra Credit Podcast and the Federal Government Affairs team in a policy discussion and a look at the mid-term elections.

Michael Grimes walks through the legislation Congress must pass before heading out for the October recess,… Read the rest

Arguments Scheduled in Davidson
Sep 07, 2022

The U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit has scheduled oral arguments in Davidson v. UACC for October 26 at 9:30 am ET. The case addresses whether financing Guaranteed Asset Protection (GAP) brought a vehicle contract under… Read the rest

CFPB Director Rohit Chopra to Address AFSA Annual Meeting
Sep 06, 2022

AFSA is pleased to announce that Rohit Chopra, Director of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB) will address the 2022 AFSA Annual Meeting held at The Breakers in Palm Beach, FL from October 23-26.

Director Chopra was confirmed… Read the rest

September Featured Business Partner | Allied Solutions
Sep 06, 2022

The featured AFSA Business Partner for September is Allied Solutions. We asked them a few questions about the value of AFSA membership and some of the opportunities or challenges they face in 2022. Learn more at alliedsolutions.net.

What Read the rest

Road to Recovery? An Economic Status Report
Sep 01, 2022

Join Danielle DiMartino Booth, CEO & Chief Strategist for Quill Intelligence LLC, and Steve Riccuitto, Chief Economist of Mizuho Securities USA at the 2022 AFSA Annual Meeting for a lively examination of the U.S. and global economies,… Read the rest

SGA Publishes Installment Lending Licensing Survey
Aug 22, 2022

AFSA’s State Government Affairs (SGA) team published a new 50-state survey on installment lending licensing. The survey provides an overview of state licensing requirements. In 34 states and the District of Columbia licensees can applyRead the rest

AFSA Comments on CA DFPI Proposed Rule
Aug 19, 2022

This week, AFSA’s State Government Affairs (SGA) team, in collaboration with the California Financial Services Association (CFSA), sent a letter to the California Department of Financial Protection and Innovation (DFPI) regarding DFPI’sRead the rest

Ready for a CFPB Auto Finance Examination on VPP processes?
Aug 18, 2022

Ready for a CFPB Auto Finance Examination on VPP processes?
A consumer case study may show you are not

The CFPB, state attorneys general, and other regulators have increased their focus on lender practices for cancelling and refunding voluntary… Read the rest

Bureau Rule on Digital Marketing
Aug 18, 2022

The CFPB recently released an interpretive rule articulating its view regarding digital marketing and the definition of service provider under Dodd-Frank (or the Consumer Financial Protection Act as codified).  Companies that meet the… Read the rest

1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 109