The Washington Post recently made waves when its owner announced that the paper’s opinion section would focus on issues related to personal liberties and the free market. Which raises the question: why a full-throated – and inaccurate – defense of the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, which at times has taken a jaundiced view of the issues on which the Post is newly refocused?
In its editorial, “Why Americans need the CFPB” the Post argues that removing the Bureau’s consumer protection “guardrails” is the goal of “its detractors.” This is a misrepresentation and fails to acknowledge several key points.
First, the financial services industry – with or without the CFPB – is highly and well-regulated at both the federal and state levels. The notion that there are no guardrails or that somehow the financial services space will devolve into the Wild West with no sheriff in town simply isn’t correct.
Second, for years the Bureau has operated with no clear guardrails, little transparency and even less oversight or accountability. The recent calls to reform the CFPB have not entailed removal of “guardrails,” but the opposite: the placement of appropriate guardrails that the CFPD desperately needs if it is to fulfill its role. Under its former leadership, the CFPB rarely followed standard rulemaking to set clear rules, instead using enforcement actions or pronouncements via press release to establish policies. It failed to protect consumer data from a serious breach with no accountability, while also seeking from industries it regulates large swaths of customer data that had nothing to do with its mission of protecting consumers.
Third, while there may be some voices out there seeking a full dismantlement of the CFPB, citing redundancy of its work or extreme regulatory over-reach in its actions, there is consensus that protecting consumers and holding bad actors to account is important. But accountability should be a two-way street.
The CFPB requires guardrails that establish accountability and transparency for the agency. That may be possible under new leadership and more streamlined and focused operations, but to ensure these goals are fulfilled long term requires Congress to act. There are proposals to do just that, and we hope the world’s greatest deliberative body seriously takes them up in the coming months.
Guardrails on a Two-Way Street
Mar 11, 2025
The Washington Post recently made waves when its owner announced that the paper’s opinion section would focus on issues related to personal liberties and the free market. Which raises the question: why a full-throated – and inaccurate – defense
Industry Expertise | Why Asset Finance Firms Should Digitalize for Success
Mar 10, 2025
“Industry Expertise” is sponsored content produced by AFSA’s Business Partners’ to provide thought leadership and best practices for AFSA member companies. For more information about this sponsored content opportunity, contact Dan … Read the rest
AFSA Webinar | Transform Your Auto Finance Strategy: Mastering Margin Management in Uncertain Times
Mar 10, 2025
Join us Thursday, March 20th at 2:00 p.m. EST!
In the fast-paced world of auto finance, staying ahead of the curve is not just a goal—it’s a necessity. In early 2025 the landscape is shifting under our feet, brought on by political shifts, economic… Read the rest
Women’s History Month | Alicia Dagosta
Mar 10, 2025
AFSA is celebrating Women’s History Month by featuring outstanding female leaders in the consumer credit industry.
My most important lesson –… Read the rest
White Paper | March
Mar 06, 2025
AFSA’s March State Government Affairs white paper takes an in-depth look at interchange fees, the costs associated with processing electronic payments, and their effect on financial institutions and consumers. It explores ongoing… Read the rest
AFSA Opposes Anti-Consumer Credit Legislation
Mar 06, 2025
A group of Democrat Senate and House members recently reintroduced legislation misleading consumers and their ability to access credit, the Stopping Abuse and Fraud in Electronic (SAFE) Lending Act. AFSA strongly opposes the mis-named… Read the rest
TODAY! | AFSA Webinar | Mastering Asset Recovery: How MVR Helps Lenders Reduce Risk & Maximize Vehicle Value
Mar 06, 2025
Lenders face significant losses from delayed vehicle recoveries, rising costs, and compliance risks.
Join our webinar to discover how MVR seamlessly integrates Impound Alerts, Vehicle Appraisals, and Recovery Services into a single,… Read the rest
AFSA Joins Sister Trades in Comments on American Arbitration Association Rules
Mar 03, 2025
AFSA, together with the U.S. Chamber of Commerce and the Alliance for Automotive Innovation (“Trades”), provided comments to the American Arbitration Association’s proposed amendments to its Consumer Arbitration Rules and Employment… Read the rest
CFPB Dismisses Ill-Conceived Suit
Mar 03, 2025
AFSA is pleased to learn that the CFPB has dropped the ill-conceived suit it brought against Heights Finance and its affiliates (“Heights”). This suit was initiated by the CFPB under the leadership of former director Chopra with much fanfare… Read the rest
Industry Expertise | Don’t Get Sidetracked by Regulatory Rumblings
Mar 03, 2025
“Industry Expertise” is sponsored content produced by AFSA’s Business Partners’ to provide thought leadership and best practices for AFSA member companies. For more information about this sponsored content opportunity, contact Dan … Read the rest