American Financial Services Association - AFSA Supports Colorado Consumers’ Access to Credit
Member login
American Financial Services Association

AFSA Supports Colorado Consumers’ Access to Credit

Blog Posts

The American Financial Services Association filed a lawsuit in Colorado federal court today with two other national trade groups challenging a state statute that violates federal law by imposing Colorado’s interest-rate caps on loans made to that state’s residents by state-chartered banks that are not located in Colorado.

We filed this suit not only because it violates federal law, but because of the great financial harm the upcoming law, HB 23-1229, presents for Colorado consumers, particularly those most financially fragile in these uncertain economic times. This bill not only reduces choices for consumers, but creates an uneven playing field for state-chartered financial institutions against national banks.

As background, HB 23-1229, scheduled to take effect on July 1, 2024, was enacted to curb such predatory lending as payday loans. But as detailed in the complaint, the bill’s cap on interest rates is overly broad,  and is inconsistent with the federal Depository Institutions Deregulation and Monetary Control Act of 1980 (DIDMCA).

The three plaintiffs – AFSA, the National Association of Industrial Bankers, and the American Fintech Council – represent national, regional, and state-based responsible, ethical lenders.  Some members operate or utilize state-chartered banks and offer a variety of credit products to Colorado consumers, including personal installment loans, buy-now-pay-later (BNPL) loans, and store-brand credit cards. These products are provided in a range of rate and fee options, sometimes – to account for credit risk – above Colorado’s rate caps but below the rate caps in the banks’ home states.

Because federal law allows federally chartered, national banks to export interest rates, HB 23-1229 will not prevent them from offering these same types of loans to Colorado residents at rates that exceed Colorado’s interest rate and fee caps. We’ve seen the unintended consequences of policies like this in states like Illinois and New Mexico, where policymakers imposed what they claimed were consumer protection laws that ended up significantly harming the very people they were trying to help, while also creating credit deserts for financially vulnerable consumers.

Colorado consumers deserve to have choices for their credit needs, with loan products that are affordable and transparent. The Colorado proposal will reduce consumer options, and without competition will give national banks little incentive to keep interest rates and fees affordable and will unfairly penalize Colorado consumers who need greater financial flexibility, not less.

While this legal challenge is not directly connected to other AFSA efforts to encourage pro-consumer credit policies and protections, it comes at a time when AFSA is running a national education campaign focused on encouraging clear and certain, pro-consumer rulemaking at the federal Consumer Financial Protection Bureau.  And this Colorado suit does spotlight some of the same issues we are highlighting at the federal level, such as policies that conflict with state law and reduce credit options, particularly for those consumers with less than perfect credit.

These efforts are focused on two core themes:  First, that every consumer should have access to some form of credit, and preferably some choices to meet their needs, and second, that protections are important for borrowers and lenders alike. In this case, state-chartered institutions should be able to compete on a level playing field with federally chartered institutions.

AFSA Supports Colorado Consumers’ Access to Credit
Mar 25, 2024

The American Financial Services Association filed a lawsuit in Colorado federal court today with two other national trade groups challenging a state statute that violates federal law by imposing Colorado’s interest-rate caps on loans … Read the rest

Women’s History Month | Stacey Jones
Mar 25, 2024

AFSA is celebrating Women’s History Month by featuring outstanding female leaders in the consumer credit industry.

What has been the most important lesson? Was there a mentor who provided great insight in your early career?
I clerked for

… Read the rest

Women’s History Month | Wendy Pratt
Mar 22, 2024

AFSA is celebrating Women’s History Month by featuring outstanding female leaders in the consumer credit industry.

*Credit to DE&I Council at Flagship*

Thinking back on your career this far, what has been the most significant challenge… Read the rest

Industry Expertise | Alfa Introduces Sustainability
Mar 20, 2024

AFSA’s Industry Expertise allows Business Partners to provide thought leadership and best practices information directly with AFSA member companies. For more information about taking part, contact Grace McGurn.

Alfa introduces Sustainability,… Read the rest

Women’s History Month | Darcy Locke
Mar 20, 2024

AFSA is celebrating Women’s History Month by featuring outstanding female leaders in the consumer credit industry.

Most Important Lesson
The most important lesson I’ve learned throughout my career is the value of resilience and adaptability.… Read the rest

Giving Credit Getting Harder
Mar 19, 2024

A new survey from the New York Federal Reserve indicates that U.S. consumers are growing increasingly pessimistic about their ability to access most forms of credit.  You can read the Fed survey here.  While the Fed survey focuses on insecurity… Read the rest

Women’s History Month | Kim Gershon
Mar 19, 2024

AFSA is celebrating Women’s History Month by featuring outstanding female leaders in the consumer credit industry.

What has been the most important lesson? 
Understanding it is ok to make a mistake.  It’s how you respond that matters. And… Read the rest

Women’s History Month | Robyn Jordan
Mar 18, 2024

AFSA is celebrating Women’s History Month by featuring outstanding female leaders in the consumer credit industry.

I’ve spent the last 25 years leading the people organization across retail, supply chain, hospitality and most recently… Read the rest

Women’s History Month | Anne Kline
Mar 15, 2024

AFSA is celebrating Women’s History Month by featuring outstanding female leaders in the consumer credit industry.

What has been the most important lesson?
Learn to accept feedback constructively and use it to further your personal development.… Read the rest

AFSA Testified on DIDMCA Opt-Out
Mar 15, 2024

On March 13, AFSA’s Senior Vice President, Danielle Arlowe, testified before the District of Columbia’s committee in opposition to DC B25-0609.

Why it matters: This bill would opt-out the state from the Depository Institutions Deregulation… Read the rest

1 … 44 45 46 47 48 49 50 51 52 53 54 … 184