In November the California Third Court of Appeals issued an unpublished decision that affects the vehicle finance industry, Stettner v. Mercedes-Benz Financial Services USA, LLC. Unpublished opinions are prohibited from being cited by counsel in memoranda of law and are not binding on inferior courts. Last Friday Alston & Bird submitted a request for publication on behalf of the American Financial Services Association (AFSA).

Summary of Stettner v. Mercedes-Benz Financial Services USA, LLC 

In this case, the plaintiffs were lessees who alleged that Mercedes-Benz Financial Services (MBFS) wrongfully collected tax on a vehicle turn-in fee (or disposition fee) at lease-end.  The plaintiffs alleged that disposition fees were exempt from taxation under California Department of Tax and Fee Administration’s (CDTFA) regulations. Though California’s Revenue and Taxation Code afforded plaintiffs the right to file refund claims with the CDTFA, the plaintiffs did not do so before filing suit.  Instead, plaintiffs sued both the CDTFA and MBFS, and sought a public injunction barring MBFS from collecting tax on turn-in fees and compelling it to file refund claims on behalf of lessees from whom it had collected tax.

California Court of Appeal Decision 

In the unpublished decision, the Court of Appeals affirmed the trial court’s sustaining of MBFS’s and the CDTFA’s demurrers without leave to amend. The Court held that plaintiffs’ failure to exhaust their administrative remedies before filing suit barred their suit in its entirety.  Additionally the Court held this was not the rare situation where a customer could sue the retailer charged with collecting the tax directly, because there had been no prior determination that the tax was wrongfully collected.

Request for Publication 

Through Alston & Bird, AFSA requested publication so that this important opinion, which modifies an existing rule of law, can provide a legal framework for determining when California courts should resolve taxability challenges in the context of vehicle lease agreements. Publication would establish a clear rule that plaintiffs-lessees’ only remedy to challenge a tax assessment is to pay the disputed tax and file a refund claim with the CDTFA; it will also help curb frivolous lawsuits over this issue. AFSA appreciates Alston & Bird’s work to continue to ensure vehicle finance companies can operate under clear rules of law.

AFSA Makes Publication Request
Dec 18, 2023

In November the California Third Court of Appeals issued an unpublished decision that affects the vehicle finance industry, Stettner v. Mercedes-Benz Financial Services USA, LLC. Unpublished opinions are prohibited from being cited … Read the rest

Senators Introduce Anti-ILC Legislation
Dec 15, 2023

Today, AFSA wrote a letter to the Senate Banking Committee in opposition to the recently introduced the Close the Shadow Banking Loophole Act, which targets the ability of Industrial Loan Companies (ILCs) charted entities to exist in the … Read the rest

Senator Reed’s Lump of Coal for Consumers
Dec 15, 2023

Sponsors in the U.S. Senate of the latest national rate cap bill apparently aren’t clear on the concept of holiday giving. The goal should be to give a gift, not take things away. Yet that is what Sen. Jack Reed’s “all-in” 36% APR cap legislation… Read the rest

Jay Powell Dons His Santa Hat
Dec 14, 2023

Yesterday’s decision by the Federal Reserve to hold the short-term interest rate steady for the third consecutive meeting at a range of 5.25 to 5.5 percent came as no surprise. Indeed, financial markets had consistently in recent weeks put… Read the rest

Marginally Important House Events
Dec 14, 2023

Due to some surprising announcements and actions in the past few weeks, Congressional math will look different after the New Year. As Congress heads into 2024, an election year, here are the most recent changes to the House of Representatives… Read the rest

FTC Releases Shopping Rule in Time for Holidays
Dec 13, 2023

The Federal Trade Commission (FTC) released a final rule related to vehicle shopping yesterday. AFSA and the Consumer Bankers Association (CBA) submitted a comment letter on the proposed rule in September 2022. We are pleased that a few of… Read the rest

CONFIRMED! INDUSTRY KEYNOTE SPEAKER
Dec 07, 2023

AFSA is pleased to announce Robert H. Kurnick, Jr., Vice Chairman of the Penske Corporation and President of Penske Automotive Group, Inc., as the Industry Keynote speaker at its 2024 Vehicle Finance Conference and Expo.

 

Kurnick, whose career… Read the rest

A Call for CFPB Clarity
Dec 07, 2023

Earlier this week AFSA encouraged other trade organizations to join a letter requesting that President Joe Biden support clear rules of the road in the financial services industry that take into account both the benefits and costs of regulation.… Read the rest

Director Chopra Testifies on Capitol Hill
Dec 05, 2023

Last week, Congress returned from the Thanksgiving holiday recess and CFPB Director Rohit Chopra testified before the House Financial Services and Senate Banking Committees. While most of the conversation centered around supporting … Read the rest

Featured Business Partner | PayNearMe
Dec 01, 2023

The featured Business Partner for the month of December is PayNearMe.

PayNearMe is the modern, reliable payments platform that facilitates debit, credit, ACH and mobile-first payments, including Cash App, PayPal, Venmo, Apple Pay and … Read the rest

Warning: Undefined variable $blog_query in /nas/content/live/afsastaging/wp-content/themes/afsa_new/index.php on line 82

Warning: Attempt to read property "max_num_pages" on null in /nas/content/live/afsastaging/wp-content/themes/afsa_new/index.php on line 82

Warning: Undefined variable $wp_query in /nas/content/live/afsastaging/wp-content/themes/afsa_new/index.php on line 30

Warning: Attempt to read property "max_num_pages" on null in /nas/content/live/afsastaging/wp-content/themes/afsa_new/index.php on line 30