American Financial Services Association - Rate Caps Fail Illinois Consumers
Member login
American Financial Services Association

Rate Caps Fail Illinois Consumers

Articles by: AFSA

Even in the sometimes-arcane world of academic research where biases were once frowned upon, it’s interesting to see how those biases have real world consequences.

Take, for example, the comments of Adam Levitin, a law professor and practicing attorney with extensive time in the Washington policy world, on a working draft of an independent academic study of the effects of the 2021 Illinois Predatory Loan Prevention Act (PLPA), which imposed a 36% APR cap on all loans made by non-bank, credit union, and insurance company lenders.

The study, which is in final draft form and open for comments, focuses on assessing the effect of the Illinois rate cap on the supply and accessibility of small, unsecured consumer loans. Traditional installment loans are an opportunity for consumers, particularly those with subprime credit scores, to access a credit product that is ethical and potentially help improve their credit standing. The Illinois rate cap, however, makes such loans unprofitable below about $2500, an amount generally well above the average traditional installment loan amount.

The study finds that thousands of Illinois consumers no longer qualified for small dollar installment loans, leaving them with few if any credit options.  The study also finds that if subprime borrowers do qualify for a small dollar loan, they do so only because the loan amount is for more than they otherwise may want or need.

Professor Levitin claims the study is flawed because it doesn’t account for all forms of credit, but as the authors of the study note, the intent was not to be all-encompassing, but to show the rate cap’s deleterious effect on a form of credit – traditional installment loans – that up until 2021 was used by tens of thousands of Illinois consumers, particularly those with less than perfect, subprime credit scores.

Professor Levitin also claims that policies like rate caps help ensure or further “consumer welfare.” But it’s one thing to put in place targeted policies that hinder predatory lending tactics, and another to in name of “welfare,” put in place overly broad policies that actually hinder consumers from getting the funds they need or saddle them with a larger loan than they want.  Neither of those outcomes is helpful to consumers.

Yet, despite his criticism of the study and his insistence on policies that address consumer welfare, Professor Levitin concludes, “Put all of this together and what do we have? A paper that shows that after the PLPA the number of subprime installment loans in Illinois fell, while the size of those loans increased. And that’s about it.”

Which is exactly the point of the study. Every consumer should have choices for their credit needs. Small dollar, traditional installment loans played an important role in the financial welfare of Illinois consumers with subprime credit.  Now that option has been removed for many, and other consumers are now weighed down by higher levels of debt than they want.  Put all of that together and what do we have?  Less consumer welfare than Illinois had in 2020.

Rate Caps Fail Illinois Consumers
Feb 02, 2023

Even in the sometimes-arcane world of academic research where biases were once frowned upon, it’s interesting to see how those biases have real world consequences.

Take, for example, the comments of Adam Levitin, a law professor and practicing… Read the rest

AFSA Members Respond to COVID-19
Mar 23, 2020

Below are some ways AFSA member companies are responding to the coronavirus pandemic. Many of our members have been fixtures in their communities for more than 100 years, and when you see the responses below you'll see why they are … Read the rest

Luntz Awes the Crowd at AFSA’s Vehicle Finance Conference in Las Vegas
Feb 13, 2020

The keynote speaker at AFSA’s Vehicle Finance Conference & Expo, Frank Luntz, was no where to be found at the start of his speech. Suddenly a familiar voice that has been on cable news air waves for over two decades, made his presence

Read the rest

Military Personnel are Losing Financial Services Options
Dec 13, 2019

The Credit Union Journal published a story (subscription required) regarding a provision excluded from the final version of the House-approved National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA). The language would have granted banks the same Read the rest

AFSA Gets Into the Weeds on NDAA, Blunt Talk on FDCPA
Sep 27, 2019

The American Financial Services Association remained heavily engaged in key issues this week, submitting a comment letter on the National Defense Authorization Act (NDAA) and attending a House Financial Services Committee (HFSC) meeting… Read the rest

AFSA Opposes Un-FAIR Advantage for Plaintiffs’ Lawyers
Sep 20, 2019

The American Financial Services Association reiterated its opposition to Congressional efforts to limit the use of arbitration in contracts. AFSA strongly opposes HR 1423, the “Forced Arbitration Injustice Repeal Act” Read the rest

AFSA Welcomes Jason Riley at Annual Meeting
Aug 21, 2019

The AFSA Annual Meeting is right around the corner, and we are pleased to announce that The Wall Street Journal‘s Jason Riley will be a keynote speaker to our attendees. Riley, an award-winning editorial board member of The Wall StreetRead the rest

AFSA Continues Strategic Expansion by Welcoming Ed McFadden as Vice President of Communications
Jun 12, 2019

WASHINGTON–()–The American Financial Services Association, the national trade association for the consumer credit industry, is pleased to welcome communications professional Ed McFadden as its new Vice Read the rest

Webinar Follow-Up: Compliance Does Not Equal Security
May 28, 2019

The following is a follow-up from a webinar hosted by PayNearMe. For more information about AFSA Webinars click here.

When two things are closely related, we tend to trick ourselves into thinking the two are interchangeable. Wash your hands… Read the rest

New Proposed Rate Caps Would Create Adverse, Unintended Consequences
May 22, 2019

The following is an op-ed by AFSA President and CEO Bill Himpler on new proposals and discussions to cap interest rates.

In Washington it’s not uncommon to have policy proposals that lack common sense. The same can be said for well-intentioned… Read the rest


Notice: Undefined variable: blog_query in /nas/content/live/afsastaging/wp-content/themes/afsa_new/index.php on line 82

Notice: Trying to get property 'max_num_pages' of non-object in /nas/content/live/afsastaging/wp-content/themes/afsa_new/index.php on line 82

Notice: Undefined variable: wp_query in /nas/content/live/afsastaging/wp-content/themes/afsa_new/index.php on line 30

Notice: Trying to get property 'max_num_pages' of non-object in /nas/content/live/afsastaging/wp-content/themes/afsa_new/index.php on line 30